Knife steels compared|Choosing a Japanese Knife

White, Blue, Ginsan, VG-10, SG2 and more: 16 knife steels compared with maker values and sources, plus lineage charts and a chef’s views.

Hardness is the steel maker’s published value with standard hardening and tempering (mostly a minimum; some are ranges or reference values). It is not the hardness of a finished knife, which depends on how the smith heat-treats the blade.

Stainless steel: at least 10.5% chromium (Cr) and no more than 1.2% carbon (C), as explained by Nippon Steel.

In my experience (chef’s view): Many stainless steels are harder to sharpen than carbon steel. That said, the maker of VG-10 calls it easy to sharpen. Harder steels tend to hold an edge longer.

White #2 (Shirogami #2)

Carbon steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.05–1.15%
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
Less hard than White #1, but tougher
Rust
Rusts (almost no chromium)
Sharpening
Easier to sharpen than Blue (the maker’s chart gives Blue “lower grindability”)

Chef’s view: A good balance of sharpness and easy sharpening, and friendly for beginners. The reference point for other steels. Reasonably priced and good enough for professional work.

Sources: S31 S1 S13 S14 S16

White #1 (Shirogami #1)

Carbon steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.25–1.35%
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
Harder than White #2 (more carbon)
Rust
Rusts
Chipping
Less tough than White #2

Chef’s view: Hard to heat-treat, so it depends on a skilled smith. Weak against impact: handle with care.

Sources: S31 S1 S6 S13 S14

White #3 (Shirogami #3)

Carbon steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 0.80–0.90%
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Rust
Rusts
Features
Not confirmed (not in the maker's chart)

Sources: S31 S12 S13 S14

Yellow #2 (Kigami #2), for reference

Carbon steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.05–1.15%, P 0.030% max, S 0.006% max
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Place
JIS SK steel with fewer impurities. With fewer still, it becomes White #2
Rust
Rusts

Chef’s view: Mainly for home knives and cooking schools. Professional itamae rarely use it.

Sources: S31 S1 S12 S14 S15

Blue #2 (Aogami #2)

Alloy steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.05–1.15%, Cr 0.20–0.50%, W 1.00–1.50%
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
More wear-resistant (longer edge life) than White #2
Rust
Rusts (Cr 0.5% or less)
Sharpening
Harder to sharpen than White steels (“lower grindability” in the maker’s chart)

In my experience (chef’s view): Tough: it resists chipping. Holds an edge long and leaves a smooth, beautiful cut surface.

Sources: S31 S1 S7 S13 S14 S20

Blue #1 (Aogami #1)

Alloy steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.25–1.35%, Cr 0.30–0.50%, W 1.50–2.00%
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
Harder than Blue #2 (more carbon)
Rust
Rusts
Chipping
Less tough than Blue #2
Sharpening
Not stated in the maker’s chart

Chef’s view: Cuts without force, so it does not crush the food. The edge lasts long, but sharpening is difficult and needs good stones.

Sources: S31 S1 S13 S14

Blue Super (Aogami Super)

Alloy steel・Proterial (Yasugi steel)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.40–1.50%, Cr 0.30–0.50%, W 2.00–2.50%, V 0.30–0.50% (no Mo)
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
The hardest and most wear-resistant in the maker’s carbon-steel chart (White and Blue). The maker’s hardness figure is the same “60 or more” as White and Blue
Rust
Rusts
Sharpening
Harder to sharpen (“lower grindability” in the maker’s chart)

In my experience (chef’s view): Barely loses its edge. Chips easily, and a chip is very hard to fix yourself.

Chef’s view: Leave it for when your sharpening skills and stones are ready.

Sources: S31 S1

Ginsan (Gin-3, Silver #3)

Stainless・Proterial (formerly Hitachi Metals)

Chemistry
◎ C 0.95–1.10%, Cr 13.00–14.50%, Si 0.35% max, Mn 0.60–1.00%
Hardness
◎ HRC 59 or more (Proterial’s published value, standard hardening and tempering)
Edge
Harder than Gin-5 (more carbon)
Rust
Stainless (Cr 10.5% or more)
Sharpening
Not confirmed (no maker statement)

In my experience (chef’s view): Easy to sharpen. Feels close to carbon steel, and cuts well.

Chef’s view: Many itamae love it.

Sources: S31 S1 S14 S16 S22

VG-10

Stainless・Takefu Special Steel

Chemistry
◎ C 1.00, Cr 15.00, Mo 1.00, V 0.25, Co 1.55 (typical, %)
Hardness
◎ Hardened to HRC 60 or more
Edge
High hardness, long-lasting edge, wear resistance (maker)
Rust
Excellent corrosion resistance (maker)
Sharpening
"Easy to sharpen" (maker)

The maker warns about imitations. Buy from a shop you trust.

Chef’s view: Well balanced and very popular. Holds an edge long.

Sources: S8

Cobalt Special (CoSP)

Stainless・Takefu Special Steel

Chemistry
◎ C 1.05, Cr 16.00, Mo 1.50, V 0.25, W 0.25, Co 2.50 (typical, %)
Hardness
◎ HRC 60 or more
Features
Special melting gives an even composition. Good corrosion resistance, wear resistance, grindability and workability (maker)

Chef’s view: A very high-end stainless. Few itamae own one.

Sources: S10

SG2 (Super Gold 2)

Powder steel・Takefu Special Steel

Chemistry
◎ Not published (maker)
Hardness
◎ Hardened to HRC 62 or more
Edge
High hardness, wear resistance (maker)
Rust
Excellent corrosion resistance (maker)
Chipping
High toughness (maker)

In my experience (chef’s view): Difficult to sharpen.

Chef’s view: Extremely sharp.

Sources: S9

ZDP-189

Powder steel・Hitachi Metals (now Proterial)

Chemistry
◎ C about 3%, Cr about 20% (nominal)
Hardness
◎ HRC 66–68 (at least 65 with the recommended heat treatment)
Edge
Very high wear resistance
Rust
Good corrosion resistance (tested as equal to or better than 440C)
Place
With about 3% C it is not stainless by the definition Nippon Steel gives (C 1.2% max). The maker’s chart lists it under “stainless types”; its notice calls it a “3C-20Cr cutlery and cold-work tool steel made by powder metallurgy”

The maker has issued a notice (2006-03-08) that, depending on use and handling, the edge can chip or break. Its impact value is lower than ATS34 and 440C. Not recommended by the finder.

Sources: S31 S2 S5

HAP40

Powder HSS・Proterial

Chemistry
◎ C 1.27–1.37, Cr 3.70–4.70, Mo 4.60–5.40, W 5.60–6.40, V 2.80–3.30, Co 7.50–8.50 (%)
Hardness
◎ HRC 64–67
Features
A powder high-speed steel with both wear resistance and toughness (maker)
Rust
Not stainless (about 4% Cr). The maker does not state its rust resistance

It is not stainless (about 4% Cr) and there is little information on sharpening it, so the finder does not recommend it.

Sources: S31 S3 S4 S16

AUS-8

Stainless・Aichi Steel

Chemistry
◎ C 0.70–0.80, Cr 13.00–14.50, Mo 0.10–0.30, V 0.10–0.25 (%)
Hardness
– Reference value HRC 59.0 (Aichi Steel group company table; still being checked)
Features
13% Cr steel with more carbon plus V and Mo, for more hardness and wear resistance (maker)
Rust
Stainless

Chef’s view: Strong against rust and easy to care for. Common in home knives. Many itamae own a gyuto in this steel (one of the steels sold as “molybdenum steel”).

Sources: S11 S32

AUS-10

Stainless・Aichi Steel

Chemistry
◎ C 0.95–1.10, Cr 13.00–14.50 (%). Mo and V as in AUS-8
Hardness
– Reference value HRC 60.0 (Aichi Steel group company table; still being checked)
Features
13% Cr steel with more carbon plus V and Mo, for more hardness and wear resistance (maker)
Rust
Stainless

Sources: S11 S32

SKD11 (D2 class)

Tool steel・JIS G 4404 standard (Proterial SLD is equivalent)

Chemistry
◎ C 1.40–1.60, Cr 11.00–13.00, Mo 0.80–1.20, V 0.20–0.50 (%, JIS values listed by Proterial)
Hardness
◎ HRC 58 or more for SLD (SKD11 class, Proterial). Not a value for SKD11 itself
Features
A general cold-work die steel with good wear resistance and hardenability (Proterial’s description of SLD)
Rust
About 12% Cr, but with more than 1.2% C it is not stainless by the definition Nippon Steel gives

Easily mistaken for stainless, so the finder does not recommend it.

Sources: S31 S3 S16 S19

Sources

A free app made by an individual itamae. Not endorsed by any maker or shop. Some links are affiliate links. Steel and product names are trademarks of their respective owners. This app is not endorsed by any manufacturer or store.